Not the same t-shirt

I have bought second piece of this t-shirt because I love the design and the first one got torn in the washing machine (my fault). I was pretty disappointed when I received it as it is very different - both were L sizes, but the new one is few centimeters bigger in all dimensions so it is quite loose on me and looking much worse than the first one. Also the material seems much softer and lighter, but less breathable. Seems like artificial material in comparison to the first piece, although both should be 100% cotton, but this new just feels much cheaper to me. If you're just testing new t-shirt types, please, keep the older type. I probably wouldn't wear this one although the first one was my most favorite t-shirt at the time